When a new threat disrupts routine operations, managers can’t rely on a ready-made rule. Nonprogrammed decisions call for judgment, fresh analysis, and attention to safety, costs, and service. A response that begins as a one-off choice may later become standard policy.

Multiple Choice

When the COVID-19 pandemic began, Briann decided to require her employees to wear masks and gloves at all times while in the store. This is an example of a(n)

When faced with a new and unusual situation, managers make nonprogrammed decisions. The COVID-19 pandemic created a health threat and regulatory landscape that had no preexisting, ready-made rules for Briann’s store. Requiring employees to wear masks and gloves was a fresh policy crafted in response to that unique context, involving judgment about safety, costs, customer service, and legal considerations. Because there wasn’t a standard, routine procedure to follow, this decision required analysis and the creation of a new rule, characteristic of a nonprogrammed decision. Once such a rule becomes standard practice and repeats routinely, it may shift toward a programmed decision or formal policy, but initially it’s nonprogrammed due to the novelty and uncertainty of the situation.

When COVID-19 reached local communities, many store managers had to make decisions with little time and few clear instructions. A manager might require employees to wear masks and gloves, change how customers moved through the store, or limit the number of people inside. These choices weren’t simply routine adjustments. They were responses to a new situation, made while facts, rules, and risks were still changing.

In management, decisions made under those conditions are known as nonprogrammed decisions. They call for judgment rather than a ready-made procedure. Understanding the difference between these decisions and routine ones helps explain how organizations respond to uncertainty—and how a temporary response can eventually become part of everyday operations.

When there’s no familiar playbook

Organizations make decisions all day long. Some are easy to repeat: approving a standard expense, following a checklist to open a store, or placing an order when stock falls below a set level. These are usually programmed decisions. They address recurring situations, so managers can rely on established rules, procedures, or policies.

A nonprogrammed decision is different. It addresses a situation that is new, unusual, or too complex for a routine rule to cover. The manager may have to gather information, weigh risks, consider different people’s needs, and create a response from scratch. There may be no single answer that feels obvious.

That doesn’t mean the manager acts on a whim. A thoughtful nonprogrammed decision still draws on facts, experience, and organizational goals. The key difference is that the organization hasn’t already settled on a standard response for that specific situation.

A familiar analogy is the difference between following a recipe and figuring out what to cook when a key ingredient is missing. The first task has clear steps. The second calls for judgment—and perhaps a bit of creativity.

A new rule begins as a decision

Consider a store manager who, early in the pandemic, requires staff to wear masks and gloves while working. The health threat is new, public guidance may be changing, and the store may not yet have a policy covering protective equipment. The manager must weigh employee safety, customer comfort, supply costs, and any rules set by public authorities.

That choice is a nonprogrammed decision because it responds to an unfamiliar situation without a settled, routine procedure. It also creates a new direction for the store. The manager is not merely carrying out an existing instruction; she is deciding what the organization should do.

It’s useful to distinguish the decision from the policy that may follow. The decision is the act of choosing a response. A policy is a guideline that describes what people should do in a certain set of circumstances. The manager’s initial choice may lead to a written mask-and-glove policy. Once that guideline is established, employees can follow it without asking the manager to reconsider the same issue every day.

So the same subject can move through different stages. First comes a novel decision. Then, if the situation repeats and the response proves suitable, the organization may formalize it as a policy or routine procedure. What began as a one-off judgment can become part of the operating system.

Why managers can’t rely on rules alone

Policies and procedures matter. They save time, make expectations clearer, and help people handle common tasks consistently. But no organization can write a rule for every possible event. Unexpected changes—from a public health emergency to a sudden supply shortage—can expose gaps in the rulebook.

This is where managerial judgment becomes especially important. A manager may need to ask:

  • What is happening, and what remains uncertain?

  • Who could be affected by the decision?

  • Which laws, guidelines, or organizational values apply?

  • What are the likely costs and risks of each response?

  • How will the choice affect employees and customers?

These questions don’t guarantee a perfect outcome. In a fast-moving situation, complete information may not be available. Still, a clear decision process can keep a manager from reacting too quickly or focusing on only one concern.

For example, a store might have enough masks for staff but limited gloves. The manager would need to consider whether gloves are needed for every task, whether employees can get the equipment they need, and whether another safety measure would be more effective. A broad rule may feel reassuring, yet it still needs to work in the setting where people will use it. Good judgment connects the goal—such as reducing health risks—to practical details on the ground.

The decision-making work behind the scenes

Nonprogrammed decisions often take more thought than routine ones. Managers usually begin by defining the problem. That sounds simple, but a vague problem can lead to a poor response. Is the main concern employee exposure, customer safety, a new public requirement, or all three? The answer shapes what information matters.

Next, the manager gathers relevant facts. This could include public health guidance, local rules, information from suppliers, and feedback from employees. It also helps to identify what is not known. Being honest about uncertainty is more useful than pretending every detail is settled.

Then comes the consideration of possible responses. A manager might compare different safety measures, look at their likely effects, and check whether each choice can be carried out fairly. A policy that is clear on paper but impossible to follow during a busy shift won’t help much. Neither will a decision that ignores employees’ concerns.

Finally, the manager communicates the choice. People need to know what is expected, why the decision was made, and whether it may change. That last point matters during a crisis. If guidance shifts, leaders should explain what changed and how the organization will respond. Clear communication can’t remove all frustration, but silence often makes uncertainty worse.

From fresh response to routine

A decision that feels difficult today may become familiar later. If a store repeatedly faces the same situation and settles on a reliable response, managers can turn that response into a standard rule. In that sense, a nonprogrammed decision may eventually lead to a programmed one.

But the shift isn’t automatic. A rule should be reviewed as conditions change. A safety measure designed for one moment may no longer fit later circumstances, and an old procedure can become a poor guide if nobody checks whether it still works. Organizations need both consistency and room to adapt.

That balance is a little tricky. If every manager invents a separate response to the same issue, employees may face confusion and unequal treatment. If leaders insist on following an old rule no matter what, the organization may fail to respond to new risks. Good management uses established procedures where they fit, while recognizing when the situation has outgrown them.

What makes this kind of decision effective?

A strong nonprogrammed decision tends to have a few features. It addresses the real problem, not just its most visible symptom. It takes relevant evidence seriously, while recognizing where information is limited. It considers how the choice affects different groups, and it gives people enough explanation to act with confidence.

It also leaves room for review. Managers can set a date to revisit a decision, watch for unintended effects, and invite feedback from those who carry it out. That doesn’t mean the original choice was a mistake. It means leaders understand that unusual situations can change, and decisions may need to change with them.

The pandemic offered a sharp example of how quickly organizations can move beyond routine. A requirement for masks and gloves began as a response to an unfamiliar health threat. Over time, changing guidance and local conditions could alter the rule. The broader lesson reaches well beyond public health: managers need systems for everyday work, but they also need the judgment to respond when everyday rules no longer fit.

Nonprogrammed decisions are demanding because they ask leaders to act without a complete script. Yet they’re also an essential part of management. When something genuinely new happens, careful thought, clear communication, and a willingness to reassess can help an organization find its footing—even when the ground is still shifting.